Voting methods, and which suits your election
Each part of a ballot has its own method, so one ballot can elect a committee by first past the post (FPP), a captain by STV and decide a motion. Your constitution usually says which to use.
FPP
The method most club and society rules describe, and the one most New Zealand councils use. With several seats it's sometimes called a block vote.
- How people vote
- Tick up to the number of seats. Ticking fewer is fine.
- How it's counted
- Each tick is one vote. Each candidate's votes are added up.
- Who wins
- The candidates with the most votes fill the seats. A candidate with no votes is never elected, even with seats to spare.
- Ties
- A tie for the last seat elects nobody to it. The returning officer can start a runoff between the tied candidates.
- Suits
- A board or committee election where your rules say members vote for up to so many candidates.
Approval
The same ballot with no limit on how many a voter ticks.
- How people vote
- Tick everyone you'd be happy to see elected. There's no limit.
- How it's counted
- Exactly as first past the post: each tick is one vote.
- Who wins
- The candidates with the most votes fill the seats.
- Ties
- A tie for the last seat goes to a runoff, as with first past the post.
- Suits
- A field of similar candidates, where splitting the vote between them would let a less popular one through.
Yes, no or abstain
For motions, resolutions and changes to your constitution.
- How people vote
- Read the motion's full wording and answer Yes, No or Abstain, or leave it unanswered.
- How it's counted
- The Yes, No and Abstain answers are added up. Abstaining, or leaving it unanswered, counts for neither side.
- Whether it passes
- Yes is measured as a share of the Yes and No votes together. More than half needs more Yes than No, so an exact tie fails. Two thirds or more, and three quarters or more, pass when Yes is exactly on the line.
- Suits
- An AGM resolution, a subscription change or a change to your rules, with or without an election.
STV
The single transferable vote. Number the candidates in order of preference: 1 for your first choice, 2 for the next, as many or as few as you like. With several seats it's counted by Meek's method, exactly as New Zealand counts its multi-member local elections (Schedule 1A, Part 1, of the Local Electoral Regulations 2001).
- The quota. The votes that guarantee a seat: the votes still in the count, divided by one more than the seats, plus a billionth of a vote. With 2 seats and 300 votes, that's just over 100.
- First choices. Every ballot starts with its first choice. Anyone who reaches the quota is elected.
- Surpluses are shared fairly. An elected candidate keeps only the share of each ballot they need to stay at the quota, and the rest of every one of their ballots moves to that voter's next choice.
- Again until it settles. The shares are worked out again until the totals stop changing, and anyone who reaches the quota is elected.
- The lowest is excluded when they can't catch the next lowest. Each of their ballots moves to its next choice still in the count.
- Ballots that run out stop counting, and the quota is worked out again from the votes still in the count.
- The end. Every seat is filled, or the candidates left are as many as the seats left, and they're all elected.
The arithmetic is to 9 decimal places, rounded as Schedule 1A says, so the same ballots always give the same result. Your results show the count step by step.
With one seat: instant runoff
The ballot is the same. The count is the one New Zealand uses for its mayors (Schedule 1A, Part 2): each ballot counts whole for its first choice; a candidate with at least half the votes still in the count, and more than anyone else, is elected; otherwise the lowest is excluded and their ballots move, whole, to their next choice still in the count.
When there's a tie
Voteble never settles a tie for a seat by chance.
- FPP and approval
- Candidates level on votes for the last seat aren't elected, and the result says they're tied. The returning officer can start a runoff: a second round for the same members, between only the tied candidates, for the seats still to fill. It's included in the price.
- STV
- If candidates are level on the fewest votes and one must be excluded, the count looks back to the earliest step where they differed, and the one behind then is excluded. If they were level all the way, it's settled by lot, drawn from numbers fixed by the count itself (Schedule 1A, clauses 41 to 48), so the same ballots always give the same result.
Try each one with your committee
A test election of up to 10 voters is free, with every method.